Shadow Sovereignty: Faith, Narcoculture, and Power in Mexico
Sanchez, Xavier
Sanchez, Xavier
Citations
Altmetric:
Abstract
Mexican drug cartels today exercise forms of authority that exceed existing models of organized crime, insurgency, or state weakness. This thesis argues that their power is best conceptualized as shadow sovereignty—a mode of governance that does not replace the state but becomes embedded within its institutional, symbolic, and affective infrastructures. Through a multimodal qualitative analysis of narcocorridos, ethnographic and documentary visual materials, and representations in other popular media, this study examines how cartels mobilize syncretic religious symbolism, particularly the figure of Santa Muerte, alongside the narrative and aesthetic repertoire of narcoculture, to construct legitimacy, moral order, and community embeddedness. These symbolic systems, such as ritualized invocations of authority and retribution, public shrines functioning as territorial signposts, narrative mythmaking in corridos, and the visual grammar of narcoaesthetics, operate not as peripheral cultural artifacts but as constitutive infrastructures of governance. The findings of this thesis demonstrate that cartels transform religion and culture into semiotic and cosmological technologies of rule. Santa Muerte devotion provides a flexible moral grammar through which violence, protection, obligation, and inevitability are rendered intelligible; narcoculture furnishes the narrative and affective scaffolding that embeds these meanings in everyday life. Together, they produce a coherent symbolic universe in which cartel authority becomes familiar, morally resonant, and pragmatically necessary in contexts of institutional abandonment. This symbolic embeddedness enables cartels to inhabit, rather than merely oppose, state structures—generating overlapping, co-produced systems of authority that align with contemporary theories of hybrid governance, simultaneity, and embedded sovereignty. By theorizing shadow sovereignty as a fractal, culturally mediated configuration of power, this work contributes to broader debates in International Relations, political anthropology, and security studies. It demonstrates that understanding cartel governance requires analytic attention not only to coercion or economic incentives but to the religious, aesthetic, and narrative infrastructures through which legitimacy is constructed and lived. The conclusion situates these insights within current U.S.–Mexico security dynamics, underscoring the policy relevance of symbolic and spiritual dimensions that remain largely absent from existing frameworks. This work, thus, advances a reconceptualization of sovereignty, legitimacy, and violence in twenty-first-century governance, revealing cartels as political-theological actors whose authority is sustained by the patterned organization of meaning itself.
Description
Master of Arts in International Affairs -- John Cabot University, Fall 2025.
Date
2025
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Collections
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Keywords
Drug traffic, Drug dealers, Religion and culture
Citation
Sanchez, Xavier. "Shadow Sovereignty: Faith, Narcoculture, and Power in Mexico". Master's Thesis, John Cabot University, Rome, Italy. 2025.