Loading...
Autonomy Refigured: Kantian and Feminist Perspectives on Personal Relations
Pomeroy, Allison Grace
Pomeroy, Allison Grace
Citations
Altmetric:
Abstract
As it stands today, contemporary moral philosophy seeks to revise past ethical systems in order to account for previously overlooked moral values. In particular, the value of personal relations is purported to be the most significant. As I argue, Immanuel Kant, often criticized for neglecting personal relations in his ethics, remains a key figure in these debates. Feminist philosophers, particularly through the concept of relational autonomy, challenge Kant’s exclusion of these relations. However, I turn to two paradigmatic interpreters of Kant’s ethics, Christine Korsgaard and J. David Velleman, as a means of responding to, and perhaps even resolving, this tension. I begin by detailing further the charges feminist philosophers make against Kant, as well as their positive alternative proposal which they maintain resolves these worries. I then turn to Christine Korsgaard and her account which asserts that the personal relation is indeed permissible in a Kantian system of ethics, and review how she addresses the feminist worries. I take a similar approach in my review of J. David Velleman’s Kantian account of love, which attempts to resolve the tension between love as partial and Kantian morality as impartial. I then conclude by offering a synthesis of these three chapters, in which I argue that Kantian ethics is indispensable for resolving the worries raised by relational autonomy theorists.
Description
Thesis (B.A. in Humanistic Studies, Minors in Philosophy and Classical Studies)--John Cabot University, Spring 2025.
Date
2025
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Collections
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Keywords
Modern ethics, Immanuel Kant, 1724-1804, Feminist theory
Citation
Pomeroy, Allison Grace. "Autonomy Refigured: Kantian and Feminist Perspectives on Personal Relations". BA Thesis, John Cabot University, Rome, Italy. 2025.